http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/-t1.htm Debates. ARCHIVE ONLY!! Wed, 02 Jul 2008 05:20:07 GMT 10 http://i46.servimg.com/u/f46/12/26/79/28/mainlo11.gif http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/-t1.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/start-thinking-t671.htm Hope
I don't have anything as of yet, just wondering if I could put some ideas out there and then debate the side that isn't choosen if my topic is choosen. Eesh, even I am confused!!]]> Debate Club Wed, 02 Jul 2008 05:20:07 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/start-thinking-t671.htm#9883 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/start-thinking-t671.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/debate-hope-v-sunburnedpenguin-winner-announced-t633.htm StitchExp626 The wait is over and congratulations go to the reigning champion Hope who has won her second debate. Well done both Hope and SunburnedPenguin. A well argued and exciting debate was had. Welcome to the latest debate between our current champion Hope and the latest challenger for the throne, Sunburned Penguin. The same rules apply as last time, the challenge is open for questions for 48 hours, when a poll will be added to decide the winner. Good luck to you both, may the best side win!!! The ... Debate Club Wed, 25 Jun 2008 09:22:14 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/debate-hope-v-sunburnedpenguin-winner-announced-t633.htm#8959 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/debate-hope-v-sunburnedpenguin-winner-announced-t633.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/i-m-open-for-challenges-t564.htm Hope
much love,
Hope]]> Debate Club Thu, 12 Jun 2008 18:00:06 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/i-m-open-for-challenges-t564.htm#6965 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/i-m-open-for-challenges-t564.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/the-cerberus-autonomous-or-controlled-t534.htm Caged_Faraday I know there has been much discussion about the entity that has been lovingly dubbed "Smokey". I'd like to open a debate on one element of the big Smokey question here, as to the nature of the Cerberus as an autonomous being (creature, monster) or a controlled force (mechanical, electromagnetic). I choose this debate, because it follows the larger debate of the show as brought up in "Man of Science; Man of Faith". It goes without saying that I choose the side of Science. The opposide ... Debate Club Sun, 08 Jun 2008 18:27:23 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/the-cerberus-autonomous-or-controlled-t534.htm#6270 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/the-cerberus-autonomous-or-controlled-t534.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/oldest-debate-in-history-t135.htm lonewolf science versus religion
man versus god
lost versus found


add on if u wish]]> Debate Club Sat, 17 May 2008 23:28:15 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/oldest-debate-in-history-t135.htm#1008 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/oldest-debate-in-history-t135.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/poll-added-for-debate-lojozz-v-hope-is-ben-a-good-guy-t537.htm SunburnedPenguin Same rules apply as last time, the challenge is open for questions for 48 hours, when a poll will be added to decide the winner. Good luck to you both, may the best side win!!! The arguments: Lojozz wrote: Lets start with a definition of Good Guy: morally excellent; virtuous; righteous; pious: a good man. For Ben to be a Good Guy he must surely have some of those characteristics but he lies and manipulates all the time which pretty much counts out all of the above. I will however ... Debate Club Mon, 09 Jun 2008 11:02:33 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/poll-added-for-debate-lojozz-v-hope-is-ben-a-good-guy-t537.htm#6345 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/poll-added-for-debate-lojozz-v-hope-is-ben-a-good-guy-t537.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/challenge-to-the-kingdebate-topics-t339.htm theggsnake Allrighty, I have three topics that Old King Lojozz can choose from. One new one and the two old ones that were not picked. I challenge you your Majesty. 1) Do you think that the smoke monster is natural or man made. I would argue that it was natural. 2) Is the pre-crash interconnectedness of the Lost characters random chance? I would argue that it is not random chance. 3) Basket-case Jack from the flash forwards- Was this always his true destiny or was it caused by his experiences ... Debate Club Thu, 29 May 2008 16:26:22 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/challenge-to-the-kingdebate-topics-t339.htm#4103 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/challenge-to-the-kingdebate-topics-t339.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/aarongood-or-evil-t456.htm Lost_Dbutz Thought this might be a good debate topic: Is Aaron good or evil? What do we know? Richard Malkin told Claire that her baby must not be "raised by another." Aaron is being raised by Kate at this point, not Claire. So what are the concequences of this? Charlie tells Hurley that Jack isn't supposed to raise him. Claire told Kate not to bring him back. Is Aaron going to become evil and do something that will negatively affect the island? What do you all think? Debate Club Tue, 03 Jun 2008 15:52:22 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/aarongood-or-evil-t456.htm#5410 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/aarongood-or-evil-t456.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/debate-msbhl-v-lojozz-winner-announced-t263.htm SunburnedPenguin Lojozz wrote: I think the key word in arguing that the Losties where brought to the island as part of plan is ‘manipulation’. The definition of manipulation is ‘Shrewd or devious management, especially for one's own advantage.’ In manipulating somebody or something you are trying for an end result that will be of benefit, in other words you have a plan to gain. So every time you see an example of manipulation I want you to think plan, because what is the point of manipulation if it ... Debate Club Mon, 26 May 2008 11:08:22 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/debate-msbhl-v-lojozz-winner-announced-t263.htm#3115 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/debate-msbhl-v-lojozz-winner-announced-t263.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/challenge-to-the-kingdebate-topics-t201.htm MyStarbuckHatesLost All righty then. Let’s get this debate club up and running again. I have selected three final topics on which to debate and I present them now to his Royal Majesty. I give him the option of choosing which one he would like to tackle but I reserve the right of choosing which side of the argument to take to myself. Or, If he prefers, he may ask all of the members of this site to vote on which topic they would like to see debated here. I don’t know if this is a format we would like to adopt ... Debate Club Wed, 21 May 2008 07:41:28 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/challenge-to-the-kingdebate-topics-t201.htm#2101 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/challenge-to-the-kingdebate-topics-t201.htm http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/debate-club-time-for-a-challenge-t169.htm Lojozz Ok now that we have all settled into our new home, its about time we get back down to some serious debating. As the winner of the last debate I would like to issue the challenge for the next debate. Suggestions on the topic can be made here. We should perhaps have a little discussion as to rules and format as the site is very different from LT's. MSHL I give you first refusal on the debate as it was looking likely it would be you bef0re the incident. Lojozz Debate Club Mon, 19 May 2008 13:58:30 GMT http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/debate-club-time-for-a-challenge-t169.htm#1428 http://losties.darkbb.com/debate-club-f19/debate-club-time-for-a-challenge-t169.htm