HALL OF FAME - VOTING OVER, WINNER ANNOUNCED!

Congratulations to Fivestades, whos theory "Numbers Stars and Connect Four" has been voted as the first ever Hall of Fame theory, with 40% of the vote!!!

This theory will now be moved to the Hall of Fame


Here are the nominations for the Hall of Fame May 2008


"Smoke in a Snow Globe" by Sunburnedpenguin - Read it here

"Analysis - 412 - theres no place like home part 1" by Angelo Comet -Read it here

"Why full term pregnancies are not possible" by Alaina -Read it here

"Hurleys Ignorance - his defence" by AngeloComet - Read it here

"Numbers Stars and Connect Four" by Fivestades - Read it here

Voting will close at 12 noon (GMT) on Thursday. In the event of a tie, voting will be extended by 24 hours.

Good luck everyone and may the best theory win!!

SBP do you just vote in secret or do we post a comment about how and why we voted?

You can post a comment if you like, its neither mandatory nor forbidden

This was a very difficult choice, and I have to be honest, My finger momentarily hovered over AC's 'no place like home' circle!

But considering the frozen donkey wheel (I flippin loved that!!) , the time-travel/shifting, smokey, the healing etc tec and the mysterious energy behind it, I think your post lends a lot to whats always being going on and what we will learn more about in the next seasons. So you get my vote on this one.

Well done fivestades

Ok here goes;

Sunny's Snow globe - I did love smoke in a snow globe And I thought it was both believeable and facinating a very good theory which could explain a lot. Although it does take on a lot, whispers, DI, The Monster ect. I have a feeling at least one of these wont be true.

Angelos analysis - I also liked this one, my favourite of all his analysis' (And I made a point of reading them all.) It was a good breakdown of an episode and some good predictions. Most of which were right. But it lacked any stand out ideas like all these others had. Still a very good theory.

Alaina's Pregnancy - I love this theory just because of the range of infomation and research went into this, (I wish I could say the same about mine). Some really good original ideas and I loved it, but (and I'm being biased) I never really was caught up in the whole why do pregnant woman die.

Angelo's Defence - Once again another great theory by the Comet, I loved the detail and how he managed to pull out quotes from random episodes whenever he wants. But still it didnt raise important enough issues to give my vote to.

FiveStades Stars - This was an amazing theory. I love how you connected the stars and time to something thats actually relevent in lost, connect four. I cant find anything wrong with this theory, allthough I think the big dipper thing is such a small clue, I think the writters will give us more about it so this theory can expand.

After a lot of thought and consideration, my vote sticks with SunnyP's Smoke in a Snow globe. Congratulations

High five Fivestades! Congrats.

Congratulations FiveStades!

Aggggggggggh

I hadn't seen this!! I have been away

I am thrilled and delighted and touched

Although I feel a bit of a fraud. As I had mentioned at the end of the post the connect 4 idea was partially 'borrowed'.

Glad to have brought it here anyway!