They "all" have to go back

by Irocz28 Sat May 31, 2008 10:38 pm

This is more of a question than a theory, but I didn't want to post it anywhere that might spoil anyone who hasn't seen the finale.

When Ben said that they "all" have to go back, did he mean just the ones who were on 815 (the O6 and Locke), or was he including everyone that got off? When I say everyone, I basically mean Frank and Desmond too.

I could do without Frank, but the Desmond storyline could make for some great TV. There is Desmond with his life perfect, back with Penny, living happily ever after, and then Jack shows up and tells him they all have to go back, and that they can't do it unless he comes too.

I think that everyone, including Frank and Desmond, will also be included if they all have to go back. Who knows? Maybe Frank will be the one that flies them all back? That would be cool. But, I was just wondering what everyone else thought.

Also, what do you think happened to Daniel and all the redshirts in his boat? Did they get "moved" with the island?

Ahhhh, so many questions and so long to talk about them.

by AngeloComet Sat May 31, 2008 11:02 pm

Personlly, I think all means all. Everyone. Including Walt, Desmond and Frank too.

I don't really see how we can rationalise from some people who crashed on the Island and the likes of Desmond that had been on the Island for years, pushing the button.

But I would also add, for the reasons you state, that it makes sense for dramatic purposes that all means all. We can then get the problem of getting Desmond away from Penny to the last place he wants to go to, for one thing.