LOST Season 4 Awards - Final Tally

Here are your winners. Thanks to everyone who voted.

Favorite Character: 1st place tie between Locke and Ben, with Sawyer, Hurley, and Faraday close behind.

Worst Character: Charlotte, with Jack and Claire close behind.

Favorite Episode: The Constant in a runaway.

Worst Episode: The Other Woman in a runaway.

Favorite Newcomer: Faraday. Miles was second.

Worst Newcomer: Charlotte in a runaway.

Most Missed: Charlie, with Eko a close second.

Saddest/Most Emotional scene: Pen and Des speak on freighter.

Best Actor: Michael Emerson in a runaway.

Favorite Couple: Jin and Sun, with Des/Penny a close second.

Most Shocking Moment: Sayid working for Ben, with Alex being shot a close second.

Best Line: This one was all over the place, but the winner with a whopping two votes is Ben's line to Widmore, "And now, I am going to kill your daughter".

Best Flashback/Flashforward: Ben in The Shape of Things to Come, with Ji Yeon a close second.

Most Underused Character: Rose, with Claire a close second.

Most Overused Character: Julliette, with Michael in second place.

Most Unbelievable Storyline: Claire's lack of grief for Charlie.

Most Believable Storyline: Time Travel Does exist in Lost.

Funniest Scene: Ben and Hurley sharing a candy bar.

*******************************************************

Just a reminder: Everyone can update their choices given the events from last nights finale. Warning, there may be spoilers below for anyone who hasn't seen it yet.

Hello everyone,

Another popular Lost site does this every year, so I figured we could have some fun with it too. Just give your vote in each category. Lets try to keep it to season 4 only. That will help keep it current. Only vote for the ones you want. If you have a new category you think we should add, just let me know and I will edit the post to include it. I guess I will start.

Favorite Character: Jack
Worst Character: Juliette
Favorite Episode: The Constant
Worst Episode: The Other Woman
Favorite Newcomer: Frank
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Eko
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Penny and Des speak on freighter
Best Actor: Michael Emerson
Favorite Couple: Jin and Sun
Most Shocking Moment: When the island moved
Best Line: Ben: "And now I'm going to kill your daughter"
Best Flashback/Flashforward: Ben in The Shape of Things to Come
Most Underused Character: Claire
Most Overused Character: Juliette
Most Unbelievable Storyline: Jack and Kate hooking up in the future
Most Believable Storyline: Time travel DOES exist in Lost
Funniest Scene: Hurley and Ben share a candybar

Favorite Character: John
Worst Character: Sun
Favorite Episode: Cabin Fever
Worst Episode: The Other Woman
Favorite Newcomer: Danial
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Eko
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Penny and Des speak on freighter
Best Actor: Matthew Fox
Favorite Couple: Sawyer and Hurley
Most Shocking Moment: Jack pulling the trigger
Best Line: Sawyer to Frank: "Hold on there shaggy"
Best Flashback/Flashforward: John in Cabin Fever

I think that their should be a category for

Most Under utilised Cast Member Rose
Most Over utlised Cast member Michael
Most Unbelievable Storyline Claire's lack of grief for Charlie
Most Believable Storyline Miles wanting money from Ben

Favorite Character: John Locke
Worst Character: Jack Shephard
Favorite Episode: Cabin Fever
Worst Episode: The Other Woman
Favorite Newcomer: Faraday
Worst Newcomer: Keamy
Most Missed Dead Character: Mikhail aka 'Patchy'
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Michael looking up at the window at Walt.
Best Actor: Michael Emerson
Favorite Couple: John Locke and Ben Linus....I know I know, but they squabble like an old married couple and its great!
Most Shocking Moment: Watching Ben release Smokey.
Best Line: Ben Linus: "He changed the rules...."
Best Flashback/Flashforward: John Locke's in Cabin Fever
Most Underused Character: Richard Alpert
Most Overused Character: Its a tie: Jack and Kate
Most Unbelievable Storyline: That Aaron is better off with Kate.
Most Believable Storyline: Walt is Abaddon (even though this has not been proven, I feel very strongly about it.)

Favorite Character: Sawyer
Worst Character: Claire
Favorite Episode: The Constant
Worst Episode: The Other Woman
Favorite Newcomer: Faraday
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Charlie
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Penny and Desmond on the phone or Sun at Jin's grave. Can't pick! I bawled at both scenes lol
Best Actor: Michael Emerson hands DOWN!
Favorite Couple: Desmond and Penny. I consider them "together"
Most Shocking Moment: When Alex was shot
Best Line: LOL the first one that comes to mind is Ben saying, "See you at dinner!"
Best Flashback/Flashforward: The whole episode with Jin and Sun
Most Underused Character: Claire
Most Overused Character: Juliette
Most Unbelievable Storyline: (I agree stitch) Claire's lack of grief for Charlie
Most Believable Storyline: Time travel

Favorite Character: Hurley
Worst Character: Jack
Favorite Episode: The Constant
Worst Episode: The Other Woman
Favorite Newcomer: Miles
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Charlie
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Penny and Desmond on the phone
Best Actor: Michael Emerson
Favorite Couple: Desmond and Penny.
Most Shocking Moment: Claire's house being exploded
Best Line: Locke to Ben "When have you ever been entirely truthful?"
Best Flashback/Flashforward: Tempted to say none (but Kate's trial)
Most Underused Character: Rose
Most Overused Character: Michael
Most Unbelievable Storyline: Claire's lack of grief for Charlie
Most Believable Storyline: Miles desire to extort millions from Ben

Favorite Character: Daniel Faraday
Worst Character: Claire
Favorite Episode: The Constant
Worst Episode: Eggtown
Favorite Newcomer: Faraday
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Libby
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: When Sun is talking to Jin's grave
Best Actor: Michael Emerson
Favorite Couple: Sayid and Nadia
Most Shocking Moment: Seeing Sayid working for Ben/getting stitched up by him
Best Line: Ben: "Fate is a fickle bitch"
Best Flashback/Flashforward: Ben in The Shape of Things to Come
Most Underused Character: Rose
Most Overused Character: Kate
Most Unbelievable Storyline: Jack and Kate hooking up in the future
Most Believable Storyline: Time travel DOES exist in Lost

Thanks for your input everyone. I figured next Thursday, June 5th, I will tally up the votes and declare the winners. That way we will all will have watched the season finale 100 times or so and we will all have time to get our final votes in.

Favorite Character: Locke
Worst Character: Charlotte
Favorite Episode: The Beginning of the end
Worst Episode: Something nice back home
Favorite Newcomer: Miles
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Charlie
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Penny and Des speak on freighter
Best Actor: Naveen Andrews
Favorite Couple: Sun and Jin
Most Shocking Moment: Danielle Died
Best Line: Ben: "And now I'm going to kill your daughter"
Best Flashback/Flashforward: Sayid The Ecomimist
Most Underused Character: Rose
Most Overused Character: Juliet
Most Unbelievable Storyline: Jack and Kate hooking up in the future
Most Believable Storyline: Time travel DOES exist in Lost

Favorite Character: Ben
Worst Character: Charlotte
Favorite Episode: The Shape of Things to Come
Worst Episode: Eggtown
Favorite Newcomer: Miles
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Charlie
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Desmond´s and Penny´s phone call
Best Actor: Michael Emerson
Favorite Couple: Desmond and Penny
Most Shocking Moment: When Alex was shot
Best Line: Jack: "I dunno, Miles. How stupid are ya?"
Best Flashback/Flashforward: Ben in The Shape of Things to Come
Most Underused Character: Rose
Most Overused Character: Jack
Most Unbelievable Storyline: Kate is let out on probation.
Most Believable Storyline: Locke re-releases Ben. He´s just to good in talking sb. out of sth.

Something I want to add
Funniest Scene: Hurley and Ben share a candy bar

A lot of the same answers as Smokette, but here goes...

Favorite Character: Daniel Faraday
Worst Character: Charlotte Lewis (does she serve any function but to be a b**ch to Faraday?)
Favorite Episode: The Economist
Worst Episode: The Constant (I know, I disagree with like everyone on this, but I thought consciousness time-travel was the worst idea they ever came up with)
Favorite Newcomer: Faraday
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Charlie
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Desmond finally talking to Penny
Best Actor: Michael Emerson
Favorite Couple: Sayid and Nadia
Most Shocking Moment: Sayid working for Ben
Best Line: You... uhh... understand Morse Code...?
Best Flashback/Flashforward: The Sun/Jin simultanious flashforward/flashback
Most Underused Character: Frogurt (did he get off the island and not tell anyone?)
Most Overused Character: Locke
Most Unbelievable Storyline: Claire (I don't miss Charlie... here, take my baby... hi, Daddy, let's go live in this shack)
Most Believable Storyline: Keamy as Widmore's heartless mercenary henchman
Funniest Scene: 15 year old Saltines

Favorite Character: Hurley
Worst Character: Sayid
Favorite Episode: The Constance
Worst Episode: The Other Woman
Favorite Newcomer: Miles
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Charlie
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Penny and Des speak on freighter
Best Actor: Michael Emerson
Favorite Couple: Jin and Sun
Most Shocking Moment: The Monster comes and Kills
Best Line: Ben: "well then its a race"
Best Flashback/Flashforward: Ben in The Shape of Things to Come
Most Underused Character: Claire
Most Overused Character: Juliette
Most Unbelievable Storyline:Time travel DOES exist in Lost
Most Believable Storyline: They go back to the Island
Funniest Scene: Hurley drives the van

Favorite Character: Sawyer
Worst Character: Miles
Favorite Episode: The Beginning of the End
Worst Episode: The Other Woman
Favorite Newcomer: Frank
Worst Newcomer: Miles
Most Missed Dead Character: Eko
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Sawyer jumping from the chopper
Best Actor: Michael Emerson
Favorite Couple: Jin and Sun
Most Shocking Moment: Sayid working for Ben
Best Line: Ben: "Hey, Kenny Rogers!" (Sawyer to Lapidis in the finale)
Best Flashback/Flashforward: Kate in Eggtown
Most Underused Character: Sawyer
Most Overused Character: Hurley
Most Unbelievable Storyline: Sayid would work for Ben
Most Believable Storyline: Kate and Jack hooking up.
Funniest Scene: Ben tells Hurley that the food he is eating is 15 years old. (The air of disgust in his voice is oscar winning material!)

Favorite Character: Ben
Worst Character: Rose
Favorite Episode: The Constant
Worst Episode: Eggtown
Favorite Newcomer: Dan Faraday
Worst Newcomer: Captain Gault
Most Missed Dead Character: Mr. Eko
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: Desmond & Penny on the phone in The Constant
Best Actor: Michael Emerson
Favorite Couple: Desmond and Penny
Most Shocking Moment: Keamy shoots Alex
Best Line: Ben - "Sometimes good command decisions get compromised by bad emotional responses."
Best Flashback/Flashforward: Ji Yeon (for the excellent combination of both concepts)
Most Underused Character: Jin
Most Overused Character: Christian Shephard. (Enough popping up already!)
Most Unbelievable Storyline: Michael unable to be killed
Most Believable Storyline: Jack's breakdown from stoic leader to drug-addicted wreck
Funniest Scene: Ben in the kitchen, preparing a dinner date with Juliet

Good topic Iroc!

Favorite Character: Ben
Favorite Episode: The Constant (honorable mention to The Economist)
Favorite Newcomer: Faraday
Worst Newcomer: Charlotte
Most Missed Dead Character: Charlie
Saddest/Most Emotional Scene: watching the moments in 4.13 leading to XXX missing the XXX (sorry, I'm not too sure which would be considered spoilers...)
Best Actor: Jorge Garcia, hands down this season!
Favorite Couple: Jin and Sun
Most Shocking Moment: Sayid working for Ben
Best Line: Ben: "So?" (that was some chilling delivery!)
Best Flashback/Flashforward: Des in "The Constant"
Most Underused Character: Rose (and I expected to see more Rousseau)
Most Overused Character: Juliet
Most Unbelievable Storyline: The way Claire (didn't) address Charlie's death
Most Believable Storyline: Jack's downward spiral
Funniest Scene: Hurley and Ben share a candybar

Just wanted to get this to the top of the list to remind everyone to get their votes in. I'm gonna tally everything up on Thursday night.

Final results are in.