charlotte

Okay at the end of the ep miles said that charlotte has been to the island before which got me thinking. One miles will play a huge role next season, I think he will deal with some of the ghosts not to sure how., i.e Christian and maybe even Mr. Ecko (I went nuts when Hurley said that) But anyways I think like most of you at this point that Charlotte was a Dharma initiative baby. But who's it could be a number of minor people that left before the purge or it could be someone like Ben yea I said it what happens if, Ben's gf that I assumed died on the Island didnt really die, and she had Charlotte off the Island. One last think Faraday is alive and he will wake up in the middle of the Jungle and those confirm my Black rock theory that I posted early. I think we should write to the creators I cant wait till January.

Someone here suggested that Charlotte, Miles and Faraday may have been island babies! They were right on at least one!

So_Lost wrote:Someone here suggested that Charlotte, Miles and Faraday may have been island babies! They were right on at least one!

From what Miles said and Charlotte it did make me think "She's from the Island". I am still trying to put bits and pieces of last night's finale together. As if that's so easily done!

CJ - I am still reeling. I need to watch it again...all I can remember is the coffin scene!

Yea that one shocked me to. But lets be real here, if Jacks dad is really Jacks dad and not just some forum of jacob or the smoke monster then we will see John Locke again once they get to the Island. Just like with Jacks dad he will be around, maybe not in the same sense as we knew him. But who will lead the others, now? I am pretty sure ben said he couldn't come back but is that only for now? Does he need everyone to be with him to get to it again? Is that the runway that was being built back in the day by the others? So many questions so much time till next season. I hope atleast that Ben will go back to the island since he is one of my favorite characters. And did anyone else think the island gave Mike the big middle finger by saying "You can go now Michael" Wow

Can they be born on the island? Unless their "special", they and their mothers wouldve died in their second or third trimester right?

mygrandmagotmeintolost wrote:And did anyone else think the island gave Mike the big middle finger by saying "You can go now Michael" Wow

I don´t know if there is any relation but in Confirmed Dead when Miles left the the dead kid´s room he said the same phrase:

Miles [Matter of factly] "You can go now."

It made me curios. Maybe you guys have some ideas about it.

To me, I thought it was pretty obvious that Charlotte is perhaps Annie?

l337Jacqui wrote:To me, I thought it was pretty obvious that Charlotte is perhaps Annie?

That was the first thing I thought of as well.

I should think Charlotte is too young (and has red hair) to be Annie.

But it does seem almost certain that she was a Dharma baby.

AC, But what if Charlotte is like the Others and does not seem to age?

AngeloComet wrote:I should think Charlotte is too young (and has red hair) to be Annie.

But it does seem almost certain that she was a Dharma baby.

Hair color changes all the time from when you are young to when you are old. I know girls who had blonde hair as a child but now it's a deep brown (without dying it, obviously lol...) and I don't think she looks that young. She just isn't as weathered as Ben because she hasn't been living on an island all her life lol, I dunno.

Charlotte = Annie? I'm gonna lean towards no on this one. Ben knew everything about everybody on that freighter. And if he knew that Charlotte was Annie I doubt he would have tried to shoot her earlier this season. That is assuming they didn't have a HUGE falling out.

Hahaha..."you broke my heart!" BANG BANG BANG

Jacqui, I've heard of blonde hair going darker. But hair turning proper ginger!?

And what Iroc said also stands up. If the childhood sweetheart of Ben's turned up (looking youthful, and part of a mission to kidnap him, and completely ignoring their history) and neither he nor she acknowedged it at all then it's a horrible deception by the writers.

AngeloComet wrote:Jacqui, I've heard of blonde hair going darker. But hair turning proper ginger!?

And what Iroc said also stands up. If the childhood sweetheart of Ben's turned up (looking youthful, and part of a mission to kidnap him, and completely ignoring their history) and neither he nor she acknowedged it at all then it's a horrible deception by the writers.

I dunno, she might just not know it's him now that he's all grown up. When I was really little, I would play with a little boy on the playground all the time and we kinda liked eachother, and if I saw him today, even if he was on that same playground which is more specific than an island, I would have no idea it was him. Even if I was sent to go kidnap a person with the same name, It's been so long, I really don't think I would put it together.

Now, Ben on the other hand would probably know. He always seems to know everything about people's history, so I can see how he would know exactly who she is.

So_Lost wrote:Someone here suggested that Charlotte, Miles and Faraday may have been island babies! They were right on at least one!

If this prooves true, I will be even more convinced the Abaddon is Walt since he hand-selected them.
Obviously, they are special.

Jacqui - I ain't buying that Charlotte wouldn't remember. I've not quite got my head around what to make of Charlotte's remark, though, but I am certain who she's not: Annie!

And Abaddon being Walt. . . Molly! How? How could that be? And more importantly: What would be the point?

i defo don't think that charlotte is annie,

Here is a picture of Annie




And here is a picture of Charlotte





not even there eye colour is the same never mind the obvious hair change, theres no way that would pass,

on the other hand i do think that walt is abaddon

Nice pictures Chirpey !

I always knew Charlotte was born on the island

I think she is the daughter of a Dharma member, maybe somehow Ben's or Annie's.. But not Annie herself. It would be weird if she was Annie. Her eyes look like Ben's, although not as much as this guy's:






But then again, most of the cast resembles each other, such as Juliet, Sarah, Penny, etc so it could be just a coincidence.

oh the mystery lol

maybe they dont remember each other, or ben has no feelings all

See, I dunno...I think those two pictures of Annie and Charlotte make them look a lot alike. Annie's eyes are still a blue/green color, they just aren't illuminated like charlotte's professionally taken photo. Annie's pic was a screen shot from the show.

Their mouth, forehead and eyebrows are even similar.


Now, with Walt and Abaddon, I don't see it one bit. Walt's eyes aren't as sunken in as Abaddon's, and their noses and lips aren't the same either. the only thing that is similar is the color of their skin, in my opinion.

It was me who suggested previously that Charlotte was a Dharma baby, https://losties.darkbb.com/other-lost-stuff-f10/the-copter-crew-and-why-they-are-there-t22.htm and i'm even more convinced now!

I think she was Ben and Annies child, and Annie left the island to give birth and perhaps was never able to go back. Annie would have had to take on a false identity as did Locke and Micheal, so there is no way that Ben could know Charlotte is his daughter.

Yeah Abaddon and Walt look nothing alike folks. NOTHING. Its funny that Charlotte and Annie are compared so specifically. Eyes, hair. yeah.... not getting into it.

If abaddon and walt end up being the same person, i'd be furious.