CHRISTIAN, NOT JACOB - EP 11

I wonder if Ben would be as willing as he is to follow John's instructions to move the island if he knew that John talked to Christian and not Jacob? From what we saw, John did not tell Ben that it wasn't Jacob, although John knows it wasn't because Christian said as much. I wonder if this is the reason that John's not supposed to mention Claire being there. If Ben knows Claire is there, it will be a heads up that there is more going on that his just being replaced.

Yeah that would be funny. *A big dramatic sequence where Ben risks his life to move the island*

Locke; Oh yeah, it wasnt actaully Jacob who told me to do this

Ben; What!
(Laugh track plays)

Yep a great ending for season 4

Thanks for your comment TheHolyStickman. I was beginning to think my theory had leprosy.

Christian told locke to mention Claire? I did not see that, brings up alot of questions. Do we know if Ben ever talked with anyone in the cabin other than Jacob? interesting...

Vincentthedog - Christian expressly told Locke not to mention that he had seen Claire in the cabin. I think his point was that it would raise more questions and stop people from considering what was important (i.e. moving the Island).

He wasn't kidding about it raising a lot of questions!

Thats AC, didn`t catch that, leaves us wondering... is she dead? cool thanks.

I'm sure Locke said 'They want us to move the island', Lostpedia has it as he but they have been wrong before. Did anybody else hear they or am i going mad?

Ben: "Did he tell you what he wants us to do?"

Locke: "They (?) did" (hard to make out, he may have said either "he did" or "they did."

Ben: "Well?"

Locke: "He wants us to move the island." Locke definately says HE in the last line.

i thought he said he to