Poll - Claire (copied from old forum)

[SunburnedPenguin]

(Originally posted on old forum)

Maybe its because I am not that big fan of hers but I really think clair is going to die and Jack wont have any idea that they are brother and sister till he is off the island. Since I have no real proof I put it in this thread. Any thoughts?

I think she will too.

I just think there is no way on earth she would let Aaron go without her, and the only way Kate could have him is if Claire dies. I also think that Jack is somehow (unintentionally) responsible and thats why he is so funny about seeing Aaron?

[JimReaper]

Personally I think she won't die.

My reasoning is that in 'Raised by Another' Claire has that dream were Locke has black and white stone eyes, and hes saying to her 'He was your responsibility and you gave him away, everyone pays the price now'

I think thats going to pay off soon, when for some reason Claire will decide to give Aaron up.

[So_Lost]

After this last episode (so creepy), I think she already IS dead. Ugh...that cabin scene gave me the willies.

[SunburnedPenguin]

Yeah that was very creepy! I think she might be drugged again as she was when Ethan took her - she was just as co-operative then - but something about her seemed like she had her total wits about her and had learned a secret of some kind, that knowing smile....so I just dont know lol

If she is dead it would explain why she is so unconcerned about Aaron

[Catfish]

I agree with So_Lost, I believe she is already dead, if so, it might explain why Miles (I see and hear dead people) was acting so strangely around her, almost in a sense of awe when in her presense. It might also explain her indifference about Aaron....

[Lojozz]

Still not sure I buy that Claire is already dead but on the subject of Jack finding out they are siblings I can't believe Juliet hasn't told him yet. She must know right?

[tracker]

I don't know any mom that would leave her baby alone in the jungle (unless dead)

[So_Lost]

Tracker - totally agree. I made a big fool of myself on the "Is Claire Dead" post about this...then Stitch came along and reminded me that we may see that scene again from a different angle/viewpoint, with Claire hidden, watching over Aaron until Sawyer safely recovers him.

Personally, though, as a mom, I still wouldn't have left...even if I saw the beauty of the island (that Locke saw) and saw the future and so on and so on. No, I would go down fighting.

[Sponsored content]